Monday, November 22, 2010

Book Review: Wish I Could Be There

Wish I Could Be There: Notes from a Phobic Life
Wish I Could Be There: Notes from a Phobic Life by Allen Shawn is a mixture of lay science and psychology with a meandering memoir. 

The author gives a nuanced and rather mannered account of his collection of general and specific phobias, predominantly agoraphobia--expressed in part by difficulty driving in some situations.

This book might give some people a little insight into the life of a phobic person. However the text is not well organised and doesn't really success as either a discussion of phobia or as a memoir.

Friday, September 3, 2010

New study into gender and anxiety

Women suffer from anxiety, including specific phobia, at about twice the rate of men.  Mohamed Kabbaj (Florida State University) has won a $1.8 million grant from the National Institute of Mental Health to look into these sex differences.  He will be investigating, among other things, the role of testosterone and a gene designated zif268, or 'zif' for short.

Thursday, July 22, 2010

Pedestrian Thinking

"Unlike the street signs in most cities (including New Orleans) that are attached to poles and displayed high, these can’t be seen by drivers. These are designed for pedestrians, and perhaps bikers, using sidewalks. They reflect a time when planners were designing the city for people on foot." [from Sociological Images]

Monday, July 19, 2010

EXPERIMENTAL REPORT: Wanna drive?

TITLE: Wanna drive? driving anxiety and fear in a New Zealand community sample
AUTHOR: Taylor, J & Paki, D.
JOURNAL: New Zealand Journal of Psychology, July 2008
ABSTRACT: "Driving anxiety can impact everyday functioning and is common following motor vehicle crashes. However, no research has investigated its general community prevalence, despite the consistent finding that driving anxiety is not always a function of a vehicle crash. The present study explored the frequency and characteristics of driving anxiety and fear in a general community convenience sample of 100 participants who completed a questionnaire about driving anxiety, avoidance behaviour, and types of driving-related cognitions. Most of the sample described no anxiety, fear, or avoidance in relation to driving. However, 8% reported moderate to extreme anxiety about driving, and 7% described moderate to extreme driving fear. Women reported more driving anxiety, fear, and avoidance than men. These results indicate the need for more formal methods of establishing prevalence to clearly ascertain the extent of population-based driving anxiety and fear and its effects, so that research can begin to focus on developing effective treatment approaches for those whose anxiety has a psychological and functional impact." [full text]

MY TAKE: This study is trying to find out how common driving anxiety is in the general public.  Moderate to severe anxiety (significant enough to have a noticeable effect on their life) was found in 8% of the sample. I think that would have to be considered a pretty large proportion. As is usually the case driving anxiety was more common in women, although general trait anxiety was the same in both genders. The situations rated as most stressful were being tailgated, motorways, fog and heavy traffic.

Thursday, July 15, 2010

EXPERIMENTAL REPORT: Driver stress and performance on a driving simulator

TITLE: Driver stress and performance on a driving simulator
AUTHOR: Matthews, G., Dorn, L., Hoyes, T.W., Davies, D.R., Glendon, A.I., Taylor, R.G.
JOURNAL: Hum Factors. 1998 Mar;40(1):136-49.
ABSTRACT:  "Effects of stress on driving performance can depend on the nature of driver's stress reactions and on the traffic environment. In an experimental study, we assessed multiple dimensions of vulnerability to driver stress by a questionnaire that was validated in previous field studies and related those dimensions to performance on a driving simulator. Results were broadly consistent with prediction. A dimension of habitual dislike of driving was associated with reduced control skills, greater caution, and disturbance of moods. A measure of aggressive driving predicted more frequent and more error-prone overtaking, which are effects attributed to the use of confrontive coping strategies in interaction with other vehicles. An alertness measure predicted speed of reaction to pedestrian hazards. This research has practical applications for system design, automated monitoring of driver performance, selection and assessment of drivers, and training."
 
MY TAKE ON IT: One thing that seems to be missing for discussion of driving phobia is the extent to which it is not purely irrational.  This study shows that dislike of driving was associated with having poorer driving control skills making more frequent driving errors, caution when driving and stress. The suggestion is that stressed drivers might not have any more accidents, but this may be not because they have normal skill levels, but because the avoid taking risks.

Saturday, May 15, 2010

Review (in progress)

Driving anxiety (also called driving phobia) is more common than many people realise, including those suffering from the condition who often suffer in silence or experience considerabel ridicule. Driving anxiety is a "situational phobia" distinguished mainly by the symptoms of fear or anxiety in relation to driving and avoidance of driving either in general or under certain circumstances (such as one freeways).

The role of instigating events

Motor vehicle accident
It may occur as a result of a motor vehicle accident (Mayou, 2002; Vingilis, 1996). After an accident about half of drivers reduce their driving behavior, but the effect is generally temporary (Rajalin & Summala, 1997).

No instigating event
There is a tendency to assume psychological disorders have an instigating event, or to assume an events immediately prior to the onset fo severe symptoms are causal. However many psychological conditions are known to occur without any obvious precipitating conflict, trauma or significant experience. For example: 45% of hoarders do not report any stressful life event before the onset of their maladaptive behavior (Grisham et al, 2006). Many people develop driving anxiety despite never experiencing a motor vehicle accident (Taylor et al, 2000; Taylor & Deane, 1999). At this time driving anxiety is still commony assumed to be a learned fear but this assumotion is being considerably undermined as more data is collected (see Poulton & Menzies, 2002). It is possble that diving phobia has more of a evolutionary/biological basis, like the fear of spiders.

Predisposing Factors

Gender
Suffers of driving anxiety are more likely to me female than male (e.g. Levinson, 1989; Taylor & Paki, 2008).

Vestibular Function
It has been suggested that individuals with impaired vestibular (inner ear) function might be more likely to develop phobias sich as driving anxiety, due to their increased likelihood if experiencing feelings such as vertigo, nausea and disorientation (Levinson, 1989)

Measuring driving anxiety
Driving situations can be safely reprodiced using 'virtual reality' and simulators (Matthews et al, 1998). And driving anxiety can be measured in a range of ways including verbal reports and physiological responses including heart rate, skin conductivity and salivary cortisol (Alpers et al, 2003).

Treating driving anxiety
There are three general approaches to treatment: Pavlovian, psychoanalysis, and cognitive therapy.

Pavlovian approaches required controlled exposure to the stressful situation. As real driving situation can be uncontrolled and dangerous, virtual reality is being explored as an alternative (Wald & Turner, 2007; Mühlberger, 2007). Virtual relaity is defined as a computer generated environment that a person can interact with (Gorini & Riva, 2008).

References
  • Alpers GW et al 2003 Salivary cortisol response during exposure treatment in driving phobics. Psychosomatic Medicine 65:679-687.
  • Grisham JR Frost RO Steketee G Kim HJ Hood S 2006 Age of onset of compulsive hoarding' Journal of Anxiety Disorders 20 675-686.
  • Mühlberger A, Bülthoff HH, Wiedemann G, Pauli P 2007 Virtual reality for the psychophysiological assessment of phobic fear: responses during virtual tunnel driving. Psychological Assessment 19 340-6.
  • Poulton, R & menzies, R.G. (2002). Non-associative fear aquisition: a review of the evidence for retrospective and longitudinal research. Behaviour Research and Therapy 40, 127-149.